The $1 Million Tweet: A Cautionary Tale for Business Communication Students

business communication instructor
You're teaching the next generation of business professionals how to leverage social media for success. But amidst the excitement of connecting with customers and building brand awareness, it's crucial to remind students about the potential pitfalls of careless clicking. This article examines some of the most costly social media blunders in business history, providing concrete examples and practical advice you can share with your students to help them avoid similar mistakes.

From Viral Marketing to Viral Mishaps: The High Cost of Social Media Blunders

Social media's power to reach millions instantly is undeniable. But this same power can quickly turn into a liability if not handled with care. Let's explore a few cautionary tales:

1. Snapchat's $1.3 Billion Influencer Implosion: In 2018, reality TV star Kylie Jenner tweeted, "sooo does anyone else not open Snapchat anymore? Or is it just me… ugh this is so sad." Within a day, Snapchat's parent company, Snap Inc., saw its stock plummet, wiping out $1.3 billion in market value. Lesson for Students: Influencer opinions matter, and a single negative comment can have a significant impact on a company's reputation and financial health. Remind students to be mindful of the power they hold as social media users.

2. US Airways' NSFW Fiasco: In 2014, US Airways accidentally tweeted an extremely graphic image in response to a customer complaint. The tweet remained live for an hour, causing widespread shock and ridicule. While the exact cost is hard to quantify, the reputational damage was severe. Lesson for Students: Double-check EVERYTHING before posting. No matter how busy your students are, emphasize the importance of having a clear approval process for all social media content, especially for responses to complaints.

3. Uber's #DeleteUber Campaign: During a taxi strike protesting President Trump's travel ban in 2017, Uber continued to operate at JFK airport and was accused of strike-breaking. The resulting #DeleteUber campaign cost the company an estimated $170 million in lost revenue and brand value. Lesson for Students: Be aware of the broader social and political contexts surrounding your posts. Sometimes, staying neutral or simply avoiding the topic is the best strategy. Encourage students to think critically about the potential impact of their words and actions.

4. Pepsi's $5 Million Kendall Jenner Ad Debacle: While not strictly a social media post, Pepsi's 2017 ad featuring Kendall Jenner "solving" tensions between protesters and police with a can of Pepsi sparked immediate backlash on social media. Pepsi pulled the ad within 24 hours, wasting an estimated $5 million in production and media buying costs. Lesson for Students: Be sensitive to social issues. Encourage students to test potentially controversial content with diverse focus groups before release.

5. Elon Musk's $40 Million Tweet: In 2018, Tesla CEO Elon Musk tweeted about taking Tesla private at $420 per share, adding "funding secured." This led to SEC charges of securities fraud, resulting in $40 million in fines and Musk stepping down as Tesla's chairman. Lesson for Students: Executives and business professionals must be extremely cautious about sharing potentially market-moving information on social media. Remind students that their words have the power to influence financial markets and their careers.

Building a Strong Social Media Foundation: Tips for Your Students

​In the age of social media, a single tweet can cost millions. Arming your students with a strong foundation in responsible social media usage can help them navigate the digital world with confidence and avoid costly blunders. Remind them that their reputation and career are on the line, and caution and strategy are their best defenses in the world of social media.

  1. Implement a Robust Approval Process: Encourage students to establish a chain of review for all social media content, especially for sensitive topics or responses to complaints.

  2. Educate Your Students: Provide comprehensive social media training that emphasizes ethical communication, responsible content creation, and the potential consequences of their actions.

  3. Use Social Listening Tools: Encourage students to utilize tools that monitor brand mentions and sentiment to identify potential issues before they escalate.

  4. Create a Crisis Management Plan: Help students develop a clear protocol for addressing social media crises, including designated spokespersons and pre-approved response templates.

  5. Stay Authentic and Transparent: Remind students that when mistakes happen, it's best to own up to them quickly and sincerely. Trying to cover up errors often leads to bigger problems.

  6. Consider the Broader Context: Encourage students to be aware of current events and social issues that might impact how their content is perceived.

  7. Use Platform-Specific Strategies: Teach students to tailor their approach to each social media platform's unique culture and audience expectations. 

Excellence in Business Communication: Navigating the Social Media Minefield

Excellence in Business Communication equips students with the foundational knowledge and skills essential for navigating the complexities of social media communication in today's business world. The text's emphasis on audience analysis, ethical communication, clarity, and conciseness directly addresses the pitfalls highlighted in the article's case studies.

The book's comprehensive approach to communication theory and practice provides students with a framework for understanding the power of language and visual communication. This understanding is crucial for avoiding the pitfalls of careless posting, like the US Airways' NSFW fiasco, and for crafting messages that resonate with target audiences, as seen in the Pepsi debacle.

Furthermore, Excellence in Business Communication emphasizes the importance of ethical communication, which is essential for building trust and credibility in the digital age. Students learn to carefully consider the potential impact of their words and actions, especially when dealing with sensitive topics or representing a brand, as demonstrated in the #DeleteUber campaign.

The book also promotes clarity and conciseness in communication, vital skills for avoiding the costly mistakes of vague or misleading posts, as highlighted in Elon Musk's Tesla tweet. By emphasizing clear, concise language and thoughtful content creation, Excellence in Business Communication provides students with the tools they need to avoid costly errors and maximize their potential for success in the digital realm.